Karen Gillan

Rachel Milligan (segment 'Conventional')

Matty Cardarople

Stu Mac 1 (segment 'Conventional')

James Ransone

Stu Mac 3 (segment 'Conventional')

Tracie Thoms

Tommy (segment 'Playing Dead')

Paul Telfer

Reggie (segment 'Playing Dead')

Megan Duffy

Melissa (segment 'Pinned')

Adi Shankar

Dex (segment 'Playing Dead')

Ryan Turek

Original Stu Mac (segment 'Conventional')

Diva Zappa

Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')

Justin Gordon

Evan (segment 'Pinned')

Mali Elfman

Lisa (segment 'Perfect')

Lara Sebastian

Emma (segment 'Conventional')

Amy Schloerb

Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')

Michael May

Stu Mac 2 (segment 'Conventional')

Trey Everett

Josh (segment 'Perfect')

Jake Varta

Joe (segment 'Playing Dead')

Andrew Furtado

Corbin (segment 'The Great Corbin')

Skylar Roberge

Grace (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Kari Calhoun

Devon (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Hayley Crisp

Dolores (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Anthony Kirlew

Malcolm (segment "Prey")

Lucas Champagne

Ricky (segment "Prey")

Justin Mokayed

Seth (segment "Prey")

Sam Uehling

Jake (segment "Prey")

Josh Elliott

Man (segment "Whispers")