Mark Webber

William Harding

Catalina Sandino Moreno

Sarah

Sonia Braga

Mrs. Garcia

Ethan Hawke

Vince

Josh Zuckerman

Decker

Laura Linney

Jesse

Michelle Williams

Samantha

Daniel Ross Owens

Young Vince (as Daniel Ross)

Glen Powell

John Jagerman

Anne Clarke

Young Jesse

Cherami Leigh

Danielle

Jesse Harris

Dave Afton

Bill Dobrow

Drummer

Jon Fowler

Bassist

Guyora Kats

Pianist/Accordian Player

Nick McDonnel

Artsy Guy

Alexandra Daddario

Kim

Jonathan Marc Sherman

Party Philosopher

Richard Linklater

John Wayne Enthusiast

Ryan Hawke

Williamsburg Hip Girl (as Ryan Shawhughes)

Iraida Polanco

Proprietor

Gabriel Rivera

Guitar Player

Greta Gaines

Faye

Frank Whaley

Harris

Lynn Cohen

Harris's Mother

John Patrick Shanley

Priest

Elissabeth Blofson

Kissing Couple

Ben Dickey

Kissing Couple (as Benjamin Dickey)

Lara Theodos

Waitress